Shopify vs WooCommerce: card fees match, so pick the store you can maintain

Shopify Basic costs $29 to $39 a month, while WooCommerce is free but hosting runs $25 to $350. Card fees match at 2.9% plus 30 cents, so the real choice is who maintains the store.

By HiKit Studio Editorial7 min readNovember 19, 2026
Shopify vs WooCommerce: card fees match, so pick the store you can maintain
On this page›

Shopify is the better pick for most small online stores.

Shopify Basic costs $39 a month, or $29 a month billed annually, according to Sellfy's 2026 Shopify pricing breakdown. Hosting, security patches and checkout come with it. WooCommerce is a free plugin. But WooCommerce's own pricing page puts hosting at $25 to $350 a month for most stores, and paid extensions at $29 to $299 a year each.

Card fees match at the entry level: 2.9% plus 30 cents per online sale on Shopify Basic and on WooPayments. So the real choice is who keeps the store running.

Our verdict: choose WooCommerce only if you already run a WordPress site that earns traffic, someone is paid to keep it patched, and you need something Shopify charges extra for. Missing any one of those? Choose Shopify.

What does each platform cost per year?

For a small store, both platforms land in the same few hundred dollars a year, but only Shopify's bill has a predictable ceiling. Here are the 2026 Shopify plans, monthly price first and annual billing second, per Sellfy:

  • Basic: $39 a month, or $29 billed annually ($348 a year).
  • Grow: $105 a month, or $79 billed annually.
  • Advanced: $399 a month, or $299 billed annually.
  • Plus: from $2,300 a month, priced by quote.

WooCommerce has no plan price. You pay for the pieces instead: hosting at $25 to $350 a month, which is $300 to $4,200 a year, plus extensions. Developer Gaurav Tiwari priced the common WooCommerce extensions at list price and found a store using 4 or 5 of them pays $350 to $700 a year. All 13 of the most common ones cost $1,507 a year for one site.

So a lean WooCommerce store runs about $650 a year in hosting and extensions, against $348 for Shopify Basic. Shopify apps cost money too, so treat both numbers as floors.

The difference is who absorbs the surprises. On Shopify, a traffic spike or a security patch is Shopify's problem and is already in the plan price. On WooCommerce, it's a hosting upgrade or a developer invoice you didn't plan for.

Neither number includes labor, and labor is the real bill. WooCommerce's pricing page shows a sample $2M boutique store that spent $70,000 on initial development and $35,000 a year on additions and maintenance. Its hosting cost $300 a year.

Why do card fees matter more than the plan price?

Card fees are the biggest cost on almost any store, and at the entry level they're identical. Shopify Payments charges 2.9% plus 30 cents per online card sale on Basic and 2.6% plus 10 cents in person, per Nudgify's 2026 Shopify fee guide. WooPayments has no setup or monthly fee, and US cards cost the same 2.9% plus 30 cents.

Run the math on a store selling $120,000 a year at a $60 average order. That's 2,000 orders. The 2.9% comes to $3,480 and the 30 cents adds $600, so card fees total $4,080 on either platform.

That's more than eleven times Shopify Basic's annual fee.

On a small store, the plan price is a rounding error next to card fees. Compare platforms on labor and fees, never on the sticker.

The fee that catches Shopify owners

Shopify adds its own transaction fee if you use a different payment processor. Sellfy lists it at 2% on Basic, 1% on Grow, 0.6% on Advanced and 0.2% on Plus. On that same $120,000 store, the Basic surcharge is another $2,400 a year.

So use Shopify Payments, or move up a plan before you route sales through PayPal or another processor. WooCommerce adds nothing on top of your processor's rate, which matters if you've negotiated a better one.

WooCommerce's own sample store makes the same point at scale. Of its roughly $89,500 in yearly running costs, about $50,000 is payment fees.

Which one is faster and safer to run?

Shopify, by a wide margin, unless your WooCommerce host is excellent. A CartHacker dataset built on HTTP Archive and Chrome UX Report data found that in August 2026, 76.5% of Shopify sites passed all three Core Web Vitals on mobile. Only 39.5% of WooCommerce sites did, against 53.0% of all websites.

The gap starts on the server. Just 12.7% of WooCommerce sites had a good server response, and server response is a hosting problem. A $5 shared plan is where most WooCommerce stores lose the speed race.

Security follows the same pattern. Patchstack's State of WordPress Security in 2026 counted 11,334 new vulnerabilities in the WordPress ecosystem in 2025, up 42% from the year before. 91% were in plugins, and every WooCommerce extension is a plugin.

The timing is worse than the count:

  • Heavily exploited flaws reached mass exploitation in a median of 5 hours.
  • 46% of vulnerabilities had no fix from the developer by public disclosure.
  • In Patchstack's tests, hosting defenses blocked only 26% of attacks.
  • Malicious file uploads nearly tripled in November and December, when stores are busiest.

That last one matters right now. On Shopify, the platform patches itself, and your exposure shrinks to the apps you install and the staff accounts you hand out. Our guide to small business website security covers those risks on any platform.

Shopify or WooCommerce for your store?

Card fees are the same at the entry level, so decide on upkeep, speed and the features you need.

Choose Shopify if

  • Nobody on your team maintains websites

    Hosting, security patches and checkout are included in the plan, starting at $29 a month billed annually on Basic.

  • Mobile speed matters to your sales

    In August 2026, 76.5% of Shopify sites passed all three Core Web Vitals on mobile, against 39.5% of WooCommerce sites (CartHacker, HTTP Archive data).

  • You'll use Shopify Payments

    You pay 2.9% plus 30 cents per online sale on Basic and skip the 2% surcharge Shopify adds for other processors.

  • You're starting from zero

    There's no existing WordPress traffic to protect, so the platform with the fewest moving parts wins.

Choose WooCommerce if

  • Your WordPress site already ranks

    Keeping the store inside the site that earns your search traffic avoids a risky split or migration.

  • Someone is paid to patch it

    Patchstack found heavily exploited WordPress flaws hit mass exploitation in a median of 5 hours in 2025. Weekly updates aren't optional.

  • You sell subscriptions or complex variants

    WooCommerce Subscriptions is a flat $279 a year, and WooCommerce sets no cap on variants or selling markets.

  • You want your own processor rate

    WooCommerce adds no fee on top of your processor, so a negotiated rate is yours to keep.

When is WooCommerce the better choice?

WooCommerce wins when your content already ranks on WordPress and your store needs something Shopify caps or rents back to you. We'd pick it when all three of these are true:

  1. Your WordPress site already brings in search traffic, and splitting the store onto another domain or platform would put it at risk.
  2. You pay a developer or a maintenance plan to update plugins weekly and watch for security alerts.
  3. You need a feature Shopify limits or charges a percentage for.

The third point is real, though the best list of it comes from WooCommerce itself, so read it as a sales pitch. Its comparison table says Shopify allows up to 2,048 variants per product and 3 option types. Shopify Basic includes 3 markets for localized selling. WooCommerce has no limit on either.

Subscriptions are the clearest case. The WooCommerce marketplace lists WooCommerce Subscriptions at a flat $279 a year, while WooCommerce says Shopify stores pay roughly 1% to 3% through subscription apps. On a store billing $10,000 a month in renewals, a percentage fee outgrows a flat fee fast.

Ownership is the last argument. Your code, data and checkout stay yours on WooCommerce, and you can swap hosts or processors without asking permission.

If none of this describes you, the flexibility is something you'll pay a developer to use and never need. Our comparison of Webflow, WordPress and custom code covers the same trade-off for sites that don't sell online.

Do you need Shopify to sell inside ChatGPT?

No. Shopify's Agentic plan costs $0 a month and has no storefront. It sends your catalog into ChatGPT, Gemini, Copilot and Perplexity, and you pay card rates from 2.9% plus 30 cents when something sells, per Shero Commerce's 2026 pricing guide.

Ecomm.design describes the plan as built for merchants on other platforms. In plain terms, a WooCommerce store can sit in AI shopping results without moving.

Stores already on Shopify get this without a second plan. According to Craftberry's merchant guide, eligible products are listed in ChatGPT, Google AI Mode, Gemini, Copilot and Meta AI through Shopify Catalog, with no extra Shopify fee. ChatGPT sends the shopper to your own checkout to finish the purchase.

So AI channels aren't a reason to switch platforms in 2026. Clean product data is the real requirement: specific titles, full specs, accurate stock and real prices. Agents can't recommend what they can't read.

We cover which products sell well through AI agents, and which don't, in our guide to agentic commerce for small businesses.

Should you move a store you already have?

Usually not, unless the current platform is costing you sales or developer hours every month. Switching costs real money, and it puts your rankings at risk.

These are the signs a move pays for itself:

  • Your WooCommerce store fails Core Web Vitals on mobile, and better hosting didn't fix it.
  • Plugin updates break checkout or shipping more than once a year.
  • You pay a developer every month just to keep things working, not to add anything.
  • On Shopify, you've built your own features through workaround apps and percentage fees.

The biggest risk in any move is search traffic. Shopify uses fixed URL patterns for products and collections, so most of your old URLs will change and each one needs a 301 redirect. Our checklist for redesigning without losing SEO applies line for line.

Don't move during the holidays. Plan the switch for January or February, when traffic is low and mistakes are cheap.

If you're starting fresh, start on Shopify and spend the money you save on product photos and an abandoned cart recovery flow. If you're staying on WooCommerce, budget for upkeep the way you'd budget for rent; our website care plan covers the weekly updates and monitoring. We build and migrate stores on both platforms through our ecommerce service. Tell us what you sell and what you're on now, and we'll tell you whether to stay, fix or move.

FAQ

Questions, answered.

What store owners ask before choosing a platform.

Only on paper. The WooCommerce plugin is free, but its own pricing page puts hosting at $25 to $350 a month and extensions at $29 to $299 a year each, so a lean store runs about $650 a year against $348 for Shopify Basic billed annually. Card fees are the same 2.9% plus 30 cents at the entry level, and developer time usually decides which one ends up cheaper.

Not if you use Shopify Payments, where you pay only the card rate of 2.9% plus 30 cents online on Basic. If you use another processor, Shopify adds 2% on Basic, 1% on Grow, 0.6% on Advanced and 0.2% on Plus. On a store selling $120,000 a year, that's $2,400 extra on Basic.

It can be, but only with weekly maintenance. Patchstack counted 11,334 new WordPress vulnerabilities in 2025, 91% of them in plugins, and heavily exploited flaws reached mass exploitation in a median of 5 hours. If nobody is paid to update and monitor the site, choose Shopify.

No. Shopify's Agentic plan costs $0 a month, has no storefront and lists your catalog in AI assistants like ChatGPT, Gemini, Copilot and Perplexity, with card rates from 2.9% plus 30 cents on each sale. It's built for merchants whose main store runs on another platform, including WooCommerce.

Switch if your store fails Core Web Vitals on mobile after a hosting upgrade, plugin updates keep breaking checkout, or you pay a developer every month just to keep it running. Plan the move for a quiet month like January, and set up 301 redirects for every product and category URL so you keep your rankings.

Next step

Ready to put this into action?

We don’t just write about this. We build it for clients every day.